Sure you could say well, at least he's been IN the playoffs but whatever - I choose to just point these plays out and hope with all my might that he lays another one...
From last year - this was the awesome misplay of Marco Scutaro's single that went between Matt Holliday's legs. In the first inning of this game, Holliday had a sort of "over-anxious" slide into Scutaro if you recall, so it was baseball karma, kinda.
This was from game 2 of the 2009 NLDS, Cards vs Dodgers where Holliday "lost" James Loney's liner to left, and it hit him in the stomach or chest. It looked to me like he blocked it like a goalie. Dodgers 3 Cardinals 2.
Dodgers go on to sweep the Cards.
And I think Matt has the distinction of being the subject of my first wedgie painting, back when he was with Colorado back in 2007. Holliday got picked off by Boston's Jonathan Papelbon.
So anyway...HEY MATT HOLLIDAY! NOONAN!
By the way, if Holliday should actually perform as I hope, I would gladly take suggestions for the next illustration. Wedgie, obviously, has been taken.